The Despised Ones: A Bloggers Collective

316243_10152853452075077_756394589_nYou may have noticed that an eery looking emblem recently appeared on my blog with some Greek and Hebrew along with a reference to 1 Corinthians 1:28, one of my favorite verses in the Bible: “He has chosen the despised ones and those who are not to bring to nothing the things that are.” Several nights ago, I got into a casual conversation with my blogger friends Zach Hoag and T.C. Moore. We decided to join forces in some fashion under the banner of “The Despised Ones.” We made a logo and invited some friends to join us, whatever it is that we will end up doing.

It all started when T.C. Moore wrote the following as his facebook status update:

There’s a peculiar tribe of radicals discovering they are not alone. They come from all different traditions and expressions of the church, but they share many common characteristics:
Their message is centered on Jesus the Messiah; their definition of power is the cruciform love of God revealed on the Cross; they proclaim Jesus Lord and King, not Caesar; they won’t bow down to nationalistic idolatry, nor will they be co-opted by any of the powers that be; their Gospel is good news to those on the margins; they live in authentic community in eschatological hope; they embody the life of the age to come; they live as pilgrims and sojourners in this world, because God is building a new city among them; they live in solidarity with the hurting, and celebrate the new covenant with joy; God is using them to renew all things.

They are Jesus-disciples, and they are turning the world upside-down.

This sounded a lot like what 1 Corinthians 1:28 says, so I shared it with T.C. and Zach. Essentially what we’re talking about is a specific set of priorities in thinking about the shape of the kingdom of God and the vocation of Christian disciples. When Jesus calls us to take up our crosses and follow Him, He’s not just telling us to engage in “self-sacrifice” through accruing a certain quota of volunteer service hours or smiling pleasantly a certain number of times at people who are being unpleasant to us. Taking up your cross is not about carrying a heavy load; it’s about renouncing your social status.

To take up your cross in a literal, 1st century sense would mean to join the procession of those who have been condemned to die in their march out of the city gates, which in figurative 21st century terms would mean to join the company of those who are despised by the world, the modern-day equivalents of “the prostitutes and tax collectors [who] are entering the kingdom of heaven ahead of [those who think they are the gatekeepers of heaven]” (Matthew 21:31). I’ll let you fill in those blanks. It means that we sit at the feet of those who are despised by the world and allow them to teach and judge us.

In 1 Corinthians 6:4, Paul makes a very interesting statement that I happen to think has been mistranslated by just about every English version of the Bible. The Corinthians had been in a power struggle which has gotten ugly and turned litigious. Particularly scandalous to Paul is that believers have gone outside of the church to the pagan courts to rule in their disputes. Paul says in Greek, βιωτικὰ μὲν οὖν κριτήρια ἐὰν ἔχητε, τοὺς ἐξουθενημένους ἐν τῇ ἐκκλησίᾳ τούτους καθίζετε.

The NRSV translates this: “If you have ordinary cases, then, do you appoint as judges those who have no standing in the church?” The NIV says, “Therefore, if you have disputes about such matters, do you ask for a ruling from those whose way of life is scorned in the church?” It is very telling about the Bible translators of the NRSV and NIV that they could not conceive of the possibility that when Paul uses the phrase ἐξουθενημένους (“despised ones”), he might not be making his own moralistic judgment about the people he’s talking about. They must not have looked back to 1 Corinthians 1:28 where Paul uses the same word in a slightly different form, ἐξουθενημένα, to talk about the people whom God has anointed to “bring to nothing the things that are.”

If we take Paul’s statement at face value without making a moralistic judgment about the ἐξουθενημένους, then what Paul is saying literally is this: “Therefore if you have disputes about daily life, then let the despised ones in your church be the judges.” Recall that 1 Corinthians is the book where Paul exclaims, “Has not God made foolish the wisdom of the world?” (1 Corinthians 1:20). We think we’re so sophisticated, but the truth is that outsiders who have no status and thus no artifice could probably do a better job of resolving our silly squabbles with one another better than we could. And it’s their lack of worldly dignity and anxiety over appearances that makes the despised ones people we should listen to and take seriously.

When Jesus says, “Whoever wants to become great among you must be your servant,and whoever wants to be first must be slave of all” (Mark 10:43-44), He’s not commanding us to put on some latex gloves and dish out soup for poor people once a month so that we can feel good about ourselves. He’s telling us to put ourselves beneath “the least of our brothers and sisters” with whom He directly identifies Himself (Matthew 25:40). Let the despised ones be your judges!

Jesus is the king who makes Himself the despised one (Philippians 2:7) so that His disciples would learn to “do nothing out of selfish ambition or vain conceit [but] rather, in humility value others above yourselves” (Philippians 2:3). To follow our despised messiah, we need to proactively examine ourselves for “selfish ambitions” and “vain conceits” that are corrupting our motives for what we do. The freedom of discipleship requires our utter abandonment of worldly dignity, which all too often has a lot more currency inside the church than without. We need to be unashamed to be despised by others even within the church who have turned church into a place where worldly status is affirmed and reinforced rather than subverted and eschewed.

In any case, T.C. and Zach and I decided to band together in some fashion with other bloggers and rebel Christians who understand their Christian vocation similarly and are willing to be despised. I’m not sure where this will evolve. We’ll have to listen to the Holy Spirit. When John Wesley decided on April 2, 1739 to preach outside of the official Anglican pulpit in the streets and fields of England, he wrote in his journal: “At four in the afternoon I submitted to be more vile, and proclaimed in the highways the glad tidings of salvation.” Wesley was a despised one; there have been many others.

Oh and the Hebrew on the emblem is bani b’li shem, which means “sons with no name,” a phrase that expresses the aristocratic presumption that if you don’t belong to a family with a name, you’re clearly a bad or at least untrustworthy person. In the South particularly, we talk about whether so-and-so is “from a good family.” Job uses this phrase in Job 30:8 to describe the filthy peasants whose company he has been reduced to after he loses his princely wealth and status. Basically, it’s another way of saying ἐξουθενημένα. How does the NRSV translate this phrase? “A senseless, disreputable brood.” Yup. That’s us!

41 thoughts on “The Despised Ones: A Bloggers Collective

  1. Pingback: Seven Things About Christian Celebrity | place in this world [plithwo]

  2. Regarding 1 Cor. 6:4, it seems only the KJV translation agrees with your reading, but it makes more sense to me than saying a secular judge is of “no account” in the church and more in line with the ‘backwards-ness’ of the Kingdom.

    I’ve been thinking about the topic in this blog post a lot since it first came out. I’m facilitating a study with the Young Adults at my church on “our Identity in Christ” and next week I’ll be talking about this as one of the aspects of that identity.

  3. I love T.C.’s statement. I think there are a lot of us who have been in this place for a long time, though we might not have said it that way. Support groups can be a good thing. I guess the danger here is when this devolves into an “us” vs “them” mentality.

  4. Yes. Yes. and Amen. You had me at, Despised ones, however, my “church” labeled me a “Lone Ranger”..Yesssssss …please sign me up….

  5. Pingback: The Importance of Critique | The Discerning Christian

  6. Pingback: The Despised Ones: a Reflection on Identity | The Discerning Christian

  7. Pingback: Monday Merton 5.20.13 | Mercy not Sacrifice

  8. I know that I am worthless without Christ. I know that I am priceless with Christ. By all human frailty, which I know from my own frailty, I am despised. It is the scared and hateful boy inside me who despises my failure to demand humanity worship me. My surrender to Christ is nauseating to the demons of my lust for domination over others.
    I know I am despised because I recognize my self-hatred. And through Christ I rise, with Christ, above it. I don’t have to merit being a despised one. I don’t need an emblem. I know my despiser, as he is me. Through the mercy and forgiveness and love of Jesus I can call that despiser in me into the light, where it shrivels into dust and blows away.

  9. Can you really just make a claim that you are a “despised one?” What are you losing based of this proclamation? Creating an emblem and proclaiming it on the web seems to defeat the purpose because it makes it cool. (Thus not really despised but liked)

    Just a thought. I agree with the concept of humility. We should be careful not to worship morality because it leads to social status in the church based how “clean” you are. That’s what leads to my fake smile and attitude that I do on Sundays to look like the perfect Christian. But we should still pursue it so we can be in better communion with God.

  10. I, too, am a despised one! To shout that to the world brings the Holy Spirit wildly dancing in my heart!
    And when I found out last month, after five years of work, that I was rejected by the local Missouri Board of Ministry because I was too liberal, instead of being depressed I felt oddly relieved. I felt as if God was saying to me, “Avoid anything that would give you earthly power. I will not let you be a tool for that.”
    The board told me to go back to my prison work with the lifers and double-lifers and death-row inmates that I love so much.
    Go back to those who cannot fill the pews.
    It was a dismissal to care for those do not matter because they cannot tithe.
    God is great!

    • There’s an excellent book called Reading the Bible with the Damned about Bible study with prison inmates. I can’t remember the author.

  11. The God-speak, the sentiments, are touching and righteous.
    But the skull speaks to the current secular cult of and fascination with death and destruction. What are we, pirates and mercenary snipers?
    I know about memento mori and all that, but I cringe when I see skulls and demon stickers on cars, etc.
    I prefer the counterculture, so on my trucks back window is a decal of the blessed Virgin.

    • Hmm… To me the skull expresses the reality of being despised and the macabre nature of a cross that has been turned into a gold necklace rather than a brutal reminder of what Jesus really did for us.

      • Agreed, Morgan! And we can look to our Eastern Orthodox brothers and sisters for inspiration, especially the monks and nuns who keep the skulls of their departed brothers and sisters around to help them meditate on their ultimate destiny on this planet. The skulls remind us that we are all “dead men walking,” and our ultimate hope is in one who has gone beyond what the skull represents.

  12. Yes! Following the footsteps of Jesus in Isaiah 53, who had no comely form or majesty, who knew what it was to be despised and rejected.
    I salute and support you guys!

  13. This is very cool stuff, Morgan. Every fall I teach a class in Spirituality Faith and Justice. It’s been heavily influenced by N. T. Wright, Scot McKnight, Walter Brueggemann, and many others. I’ve long made the claim that our task as Christians is the abandonment of power. It’s an expression of sacrifice modeling the Kenosis passage n Philippians 2. This serves as a prophetic contrast to the assumption of means-ends rationality that is the dominant ethos of modern society. I don’t read Greek and don’t have theology degrees, but my sociology puts me in the same general ballpark you guys are exploring. Keep it up.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s